I've been writing some more of The Lighthouse Keeper (always with The Islander as background "noise") and I wanted to post here the "new" version of Chapter 1.
I also would like to have your true, honest opinion: can you feel for Jonah? I really, very rarely write novels in the first person and I was wondering if it had enough "active scenes" or too much "introspection" stuff. I know, it's only the first chapter and so far, not much is happening, but anyway. You know what I mean. :P
Does it make you wanna read more or does it all just sound... boring?
Does it make you wanna read more or does it all just sound... boring?
Happy reading! :P
---------------------------------------------------------------------
(Novel excerpt)
CHAPTER ONE
I
was told to keep a journal.
Old
Gregory said it would help fight loneliness and seclusion. I guess giving it a
try now is not worse than anything else.
My
name is Jonah and I live in a lighthouse on a remote island. Oddly enough, I have never felt
the need to keep a journal before. I guess loneliness and seclusion never
really struck me.
But today, everything’s changed…
***
I
washed ashore on this island some nine years ago with very little memory of my
past. I was about ten years old. And whereas the sea had rejected me, old
Gregory took me in and raised me as his own son. He taught me to speak, read
and write English. He taught me some world history and geography. Of course,
most importantly, he taught me how to survive on the island and how to keep the
lighthouse active.
He used to call us “the last
lighthouse keepers”. I often wondered what he meant by that since he had showed
me pictures and handed me stories of lighthouses and their keepers from all
around the world. Clearly, there were others! But he kept on calling us that… I
guess now it is too late to ask him.
The
island itself is quite small. Walking on its shore, one could circle it in a
single day. However, the center of it has remained a mystery to me for it is always
shrouded in the thickest fog and old Gregory has forbidden me to ever enter it.
“I
don’t want you to get lost, boy, and leave me alone again with the burden of
this job,” he used to say. “I’m not getting any younger, you know, and I need
your strength.”
Funny
thing, though, is that I cannot recall old Gregory asking for my help in any
situation; he was incredibly strong in spite of his age. “An old salt” I think
is the expression that best described him.
Because of his warning against the
center of the island, I often suspected he knew something was hiding in the fog
but whenever I brought up the subject, old Gregory would sweep it under the
rug.
“Nonsense,
boy! If something lived there, I would know it by now, wouldn’t I?”
Precisely.
Nevertheless, if we truly were the only inhabitants of this island, then why is
the lighthouse surrounded by an iron gate which old Gregory locked tight every
night?
He
was an odd man, old Gregory, but I liked him all the same. He truly was a
father to me. And we got along fine which is a good thing, you know, if we indeed
were the only ones here, him and me.
Now
don’t go asking where exactly is “here” because I don’t have a single idea. Old
Gregory did teach me geography but the only answer he has ever given to the
“where are we?” question is “somewhere, at the end of the world”.
Some
days, I believe him…
Today
is one of those days. For you see, old Gregory has disappeared.
I am all alone now.
***
Emerging from the fog, the old man’s
small boat accosted on the white sand shore. A tall woman approached him,
concealing her features and her long brown hair in the darkness of her hood.
Recognizing the woman, the old man bowed.
“My Lady,” he greeted.
“My dearest friend. I hate to be
the bringer of bad news. He knows.”
“I know. He paid me a visit.”
“Oh! My poor friend. I hope he has not
been too hard on you.”
“The punishment is yet to come, my
Lady.”
“I am so sorry to have put you in
the middle of this, dear friend.”
“Think nothing of it. There are
more pressing matters. For instance, what will you do now?”
“I must admit I do not know. I
truly dread his wrath.”
“But he loves you, my Lady.”
“Oh! You do not know him the way I
do, my friend; I fear him.”
She clutched at her long autumn-red
coat, tightening it around herself in a shiver. The old man frowned; had he really
just guessed the Lady’s intentions hidden behind her words?
“Are you… demanding to cross, my
Lady?” he stuttered.
“I’m afraid I must, old friend.”
“But… it is not the time!”
“I am aware of that, but I am at
wit’s end. Mother will know what to do…”
Without another word, she embarked on the small
boat.
Since you asked for an honest opinion, I wanted to point out some of the things I noticed with the except. First of all, it sounds like Jonas is writing a journal entry correct?
ReplyDeleteIf that is the case, I'll add some comments: I liked your previous chapter one intro better. You established that this was the first time Jonas had a journal, and that for some reason, he only started writing today. So your first attempt at chapter one was lovely - Jonas used simple sentences and got right to the point. His writing followed a stream of conciousness feeling, especially when you added the fragment "some days I believe him."
Your second attempt adds longer sentences and extra words to make the descriptions more...fancy? However that breaks the immersion of journal reading for me - So only in my opinion, I would say make the journal section shorter and compact. Then Jonas true voice can show through his simple words.
Thanks for your honest comment! :D
DeleteI know of the "problem" you speak of. I still have trouble finding Jonah's right voice and deciding whether I should write this novel in the first or third person format. I guess I'm gonna have to remodel the first chapter completely a few more times before I find the right track to go on! ^_^
Back to work then!
Thanks again for your helpful comment! :)